I just recently switched from a 2018 15″ MBP back to my 2015 13″ and I thought I’d share some of my reactions to the change. My meandering and unstructured thoughts follow.
Unexpectedly, on returning to the 2015 MBP, I didn’t suddenly go “omgomg the keyboard is amazing again”. The older style was never amazing compared to any good mechanical keyboard. I adapted to the new keyboard just fine, even though my hands never really were big enough for it to be truly comfortable. Yes, the older keyboard’s keys really are less of a stretch but it wasn’t that much of a hardship either way.
The basic truth for me is that both keyboards are fully usable and that having the dedicated escape key (or not) was never a big deal. The virtual one did the job just fine. That’s something I never expected to admit but it’s true. I may not love MBP keyboards but they work.
I will admit the older dedicated function keys are slightly better, especially given how I’ve rebound them using Keyboard Maestro, but not an order of magnitude more usable. Just…better. Not way better.
The trackpad feels old and quaint in comparison to the newer one. I miss the 2018 trackpad more than I expected, especially given how I’m an admitted trackpad hater. Moving documents has become again slightly more difficult on the older MBP, so there’s that.
My 13″ screen now feels cramped and tiny, as expected. But I once again appreciate how clean and beautiful the Retina display is, as I compare it to my one-older-purchase, the non-Retina MBA. The 2015 13″ is a great laptop, even if it feels chunkier and less streamlined than the 2018. You can tangibly feel the design differences between the 3 years as well as the battery improvements.
On the other hand, moving back from USB-C to all these wonderful ports is delightful. My 2018 was always an octopus, and I had to carry around a bag of hubs and adapters. (I even have one on my keychain, which I probably don’t need anymore.)
Yes, I still use some adapters like my HDMI to Thunderbolt 2, so I can have two monitors running from the 2015 laptop, but that lives on the HDMI cord, not with my laptop.
I have a bunch of extra file space with the built-in SD card reader with my computer-flush reader adapter so it looks built in. The two standard USB ports are so convenient. I have an entire bag of USB-C gizmos that I’d carry around with the 2018 machine that I dumped into my USB box-of-everything for now.
On the other hand, I do miss the fingerprint reader. My experiences unlocking with my watch are hit and miss. Sometimes it works great. Sometimes it doesn’t. I can’t really figure out when it will and won’t: it’s not just after restarts or a long time between use. In contrast, the fingerprint reader absolutely rocks on the 2018, even if I had to remove a bunch of items from the touch bar because sometimes I’d turn on Siri or mute my audio when I thought I was still unlocking.
Speaking of the touch bar, I don’t miss it at all. As a touch typist I was always a little stunned to discover that it had relevant information on it that I never looked at. If the touch bar had important stuff, it should have been on the screen and my screen should have been touchable all over. As someone or other said (I forget exactly who — sorry!), it’s a keyboard when it shouldn’t be and a touch screen where it shouldn’t be. I’m paraphrasing from memory.
Every one of you who develop content for the touch bar, bravo. I am glad of how you are helping the user, especially the user who can see the touch bar and interacts with it. I don’t want you to change a thing. Instead, I want Apple to step up and get that material integrated with the main display so I can take part too.
I’m holding off on upgrading a lot of things right now. I’m still using my iPhone 6+, my 2012 Mac mini, my 2015 MBP. They all work and get the job done and nothing yet has really given me the motivation to push forward to new hardware. The iPhone 11 is lovely but I don’t really take many pictures. The new mini isn’t self serviceable (at least to a klutz like me) and I honestly don’t want to leave Mojave on it and lose my 32-bit apps. The 2015 (running Catalina) is still a really great laptop.
I’m waiting to fall in love again, the way I did with the 5th gen iPad mini, which swept me off my feet early this year. I adore the mini. Revised and supporting the pencil, it gave me new ways to use it, better user experiences, and a solid beautiful form factor making it a natural upgrade from the 2nd gen.
I want my next hardware purchases to have that same passion instead of incremental utility.
What are you buying and what are you holding onto waiting for the right moment? Let me know.